London SE1 community website

Congestion Charging

Join in these discussions today! Log in or register.
Current: 17 of 21
Wednesday 13 November 2002 5.12pm

I wasn't accusing people here of being of being hysterical - I was talking about the opposition to the charge in general, from what I've seen on other discussion forums and on radio phone-ins and the like
Wednesday 13 November 2002 5.50pm
In response to jrhartley's alternative system - it's on it's way. We (IBM) are working with the UK's largest insurer to implement a system that charges you by actually usage and the areas you drive in. Once rolled out it will have wider implications, and uses. Ken has already expressed an interest in a similar system. I predict it will be common-place by 2006.
Wednesday 13 November 2002 5.57pm

You'd better get the order from Ken soon, I'm not sure he'll be around to place it in a couple of years...
Thursday 14 November 2002 11.28am
I have to say James.

you have left your (what I always thought) neutral position.
Thursday 14 November 2002 12.45pm
Jai (Varkenslachter) wrote:

Anyway, no hard feelings

I think it's normally for the person who was insulted to say whether there are any hard feelings, rather than the person doing the insulting.

Thursday 14 November 2002 1.03pm
jrhartley wrote:

Ken's an idiot - that's generally accepted.

Is it? Generally accepted by whom? Those who believe everything they read in the gutter press, certainly. But Londoners voted him into office by a clear majority with their eyes wide open (he was not exactly an unknown quantity). I can't imagine they would have done that if he was merely an idiot.

Also I think it's childish to personalise the thing in this way. Congestion charging isn't something Ken alone dreamed up as his own personal barmy scheme. Many urban planners, transport economists etc. (and indeed some other politicians) have been calling for something similar for a long time. I imagine the details have been worked out, after consultation in various directions, by paid officials at TfL who were presumably hired for their expertise, not by Ken personally. Whether they have got it right or not remains to be seen.
Thursday 14 November 2002 1.12pm
James Hatts (editor) wrote:

People need to get to grips with the idea that they don't have the God-given right to drive their polluting, congesting cars where they want, when they want.

Right on James! That's EXACTLY what I've been trying to say all along.

Thursday 14 November 2002 1.22pm
Tony Hilliard wrote:

I do have the right to drive my car where I want, when I want. I pay my road tax and insurance. I paid my VAT on the car itself. I pay duty on the fuel I put in it, and now I will pay the congestion charge when entering the zone. It's all about choice.

No, you don't. Where in the law does it say that you have that "right"? Legally, as I understand it, the authorities would be quite within their rights to ban yours and all other private cars altogether from whatever areas they choose.

And I wish they would.

Also, as I have pointed out earlier in this thread, your road tax doesn't entitle you to anything. It certainly doesn't cover the real full cost of providing and maintaining the roads, still less all the ancillary things like traffic police, all of which come out of the general taxation which everybody has to pay whether they use a car or not.

I'll say it yet again -- urban road space is a finite and very costly resource. If a real market value could be placed on it, it would take a lot more than 5 quid per car per day to cover it.

Thursday 14 November 2002 1.26pm
Message edited to remove personal abuse.

Thursday 14 November 2002 1.29pm
Paul - you are agreeing with what I said. If the authorities ban cars permanently from an area then I lose the right to drive there. Fine. Until that point I do have the right.
Current: 17 of 21

To post a message, please log in or register..
We are part of
Independent Community News Network
Email newsletter

For the latest local news and events direct to your inbox every Monday, you need our weekly email newsletter SE1 Direct.

7,000+ locals read it every week. Can you afford to miss out?

Read the latest issue before signing up

Also on the forum
Views expressed in this discussion forum are those of the contributors and may not reflect the editorial policy of this website. Please read our terms and conditions